|
|
Post by insider on Oct 2, 2012 1:08:48 GMT -8
Almost certainly not. But if they brought in my ideal coach this program would be a consistent top 25 team that wins 90% of their games against average teams like SJSU and FSU. HOLY $HIT REALLY!!!! YOU CAN GUARANTEE YOUR CHOICE WOULD DO THOSE THINGS??? HOW ARE YOU NOT AN ATHLETIC DIRECTOR FOR A BCS SCHOOL ALREADY!!??!!?? LETS FIRE STERK AND HIRE THIS FREAKIN GUY ALREADY!!!! BYYYAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!! Drunk post much? I should have reworded my statement, but I'd easily take the risk in firing in Rocky and there are plenty of candidates that can take this program to at least a borderline top 25 level like Cincy is at, this is actually a desirable good job. |
|
|
|
Post by longtimesdsufan on Oct 2, 2012 4:27:30 GMT -8
Nobody seems to remember that our prize DL recruit went with Brady. Brady recruited the DL until this year. Funny how everyone thinks Brady is so great, but this is his defensive line, not Rocky's.
|
|
|
|
Post by fowl on Oct 2, 2012 6:08:53 GMT -8
Nobody seems to remember that our prize DL recruit went with Brady. Brady recruited the DL until this year. Funny how everyone thinks Brady is so great, but this is his defensive line, not Rocky's. Which prized DL recruit was that??? |
|
|
|
Post by Trujillos & Beer on Oct 2, 2012 6:24:54 GMT -8
6. If the admins opened the vault and brought in your ideal coach, will SDSU football to win a National Championship in the next decade? 7. Could you ask a more irrelevant question? ..Sent from my Samsung GS3.. |
|
|
|
Post by montyismyhomie on Oct 2, 2012 6:40:15 GMT -8
HOLY $HIT REALLY!!!! YOU CAN GUARANTEE YOUR CHOICE WOULD DO THOSE THINGS??? HOW ARE YOU NOT AN ATHLETIC DIRECTOR FOR A BCS SCHOOL ALREADY!!??!!?? LETS FIRE STERK AND HIRE THIS FREAKIN GUY ALREADY!!!! BYYYAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!! Drunk post much? I should have reworded my statement, but I'd easily take the risk in firing in Rocky and there are plenty of candidates that can take this program to at least a borderline top 25 level like Cincy is at, this is actually a desirable good job. Not drunk just giving you a hard time for that absolute statement you made. Your reworded statement acknowledging the risk factor in that course of action is a totally fair statement. It's a little coockoo for anyone on this board to claim that the guy they want hired will guaranteed deliver us top 25 finishes every year. No one, not even sterk can make that claim. |
|
|
|
Post by AztecBill on Oct 2, 2012 10:05:57 GMT -8
At least we have solved the problem of bad first halfs.
|
|
|
|
Post by monty on Oct 2, 2012 10:15:15 GMT -8
You can't even be part serious. Rocky won't lead us to a big east title, but I certainly believe a much more capable coach can. I don't believe my thoughts on Rocky are documented in any of these 34 threads on the subject, but, that aside, my questions was about ones respective ideal coach and if they thought said coach could get the Aztecs to the pinnacle. If winning the Big East is what will qualify as "success" to the masses (short or long term), then go ahead and fire him. The PPG group stepped-up to buyout CL, so I'm sure if enough concerned supporters stepped-up they could accomplish the same fate -- by step-up I should clarify that I mean money, not faxing posts from a message board and sending harshly-worded emails complaining and making idle threats -- but something tells me that a BE Championship won't appease enough people and the Aztecs will still be "failures" because they only finished 17th in the AP Poll and couldn't beat a SEC team in a bowl game. Lather. Rinse. Repeat. This is just insane. The gap between where we are and a conf title and finishing 17th in the country is a grand canyon sized chasm. That would be incredible progress, if a coach performed that here, he'd be a god. The status quo posters are incapable of forming an argument and just revert to absurd statements like these. |
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 2, 2012 11:34:14 GMT -8
|
|
|
|
Post by localsonly on Oct 2, 2012 12:10:41 GMT -8
serious questions for the fire rocky crowd. 1. would you say that our offense has for the most part improved as the season has gone on? 2. did this board not spend ungodly amounts of time during the offseason talking about the ?'s we had on the defensive line and all the problems that can arise from having a young and inexperienced defensive front? 3. are the problems on defense we are experiencing right now mostly associated with having a young and inexperienced defensive front? (i.e. lack of pressure on the quarterback giving him all day to throw) 4. if you answered yes to all 3 questions, how can you rationally call for the firing of our coach? If this were a multiple choice test, I'd be tempted to answer "all the above" yes, the offense has improved, yes, there were lots of complaints about the impending doom for the D with the first release of the Spring roster showing lightweights all over; yes, those problems are due to youth and who's been recruiting the D for 3 years now? Coach Rock still has a chance to save his season and his job. It starts this week. |
|
|
|
Post by montyismyhomie on Oct 2, 2012 12:21:53 GMT -8
I don't believe my thoughts on Rocky are documented in any of these 34 threads on the subject, but, that aside, my questions was about ones respective ideal coach and if they thought said coach could get the Aztecs to the pinnacle. If winning the Big East is what will qualify as "success" to the masses (short or long term), then go ahead and fire him. The PPG group stepped-up to buyout CL, so I'm sure if enough concerned supporters stepped-up they could accomplish the same fate -- by step-up I should clarify that I mean money, not faxing posts from a message board and sending harshly-worded emails complaining and making idle threats -- but something tells me that a BE Championship won't appease enough people and the Aztecs will still be "failures" because they only finished 17th in the AP Poll and couldn't beat a SEC team in a bowl game. Lather. Rinse. Repeat. This is just insane. The gap between where we are and a conf title and finishing 17th in the country is a grand canyon sized chasm. That would be incredible progress, if a coach performed that here, he'd be a god. The status quo posters are incapable of forming an argument and just revert to absurd statements like these.Where do you get off making statements like these??? there have been plenty of good points made as to why its a bad idea to fire rocky right now as you propose. For example constant coaching turnover, like having 3 different coaches in 4 years, is basically a red flag to recruits and the sign of a weak or flailing program. you simply choose to ignore rational thought and reclassify it as absurd so that it fits your narrative. |
|
|
|
Post by monty on Oct 2, 2012 15:13:46 GMT -8
So, if we fire a mediocre aging coach we might not continue to pull in these bottom half of the country recruiting classes? The horror. A real coach would vastly improve the recruiting at this school.
|
|
|
|
Post by sdfootballfan on Oct 2, 2012 15:53:25 GMT -8
Almost certainly not. But if they brought in my ideal coach this program would be a consistent top 25 team that wins 90% of their games against average teams like SJSU and FSU. HOLY $HIT REALLY!!!! YOU CAN GUARANTEE YOUR CHOICE WOULD DO THOSE THINGS??? HOW ARE YOU NOT AN ATHLETIC DIRECTOR FOR A BCS SCHOOL ALREADY!!??!!?? LETS FIRE STERK AND HIRE THIS FREAKIN GUY ALREADY!!!! BYYYAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!! If they hired my ideal Defensive Coordinator, ran all the schemes I suggested, went with the uniforms I picked out, put USD on the schedule like I asked, sold the hot dogs at the Q that I cooked, Brady Hoke would still be our head coach and we'd be in the SEC beating Alabama and LSU for the National Title every year. |
|
|
|
Post by montyismyhomie on Oct 2, 2012 16:40:45 GMT -8
So, if we fire a mediocre aging coach we might not continue to pull in these bottom half of the country recruiting classes? The horror. A real coach would vastly improve the recruiting at this school. This notion that we have had awful recruiting classes has been beaten to death on the recruiting board over the last several months and is completely wrong. but go ahead, keep spinning things to fit your narrative. |
|
